I called this when it was first announced that Seacrest would be hosting the awards and indeed, the Emmys were a disaster.
Ratings
Last night's Emmys suffered the second lowest ratings ever for the award show, averaging 13.1 million viewers. By contrast, last year's telecast averaged 16.2 million and CBS pulled in 18.7 million viewers two years ago.
The 18-49 demographic was even worse, as the Emmys' 4.3/11 (rating/share) was demolished by NBC's Sunday Night Football (San Diego Chargers at New England Patriots) which drew a 6.7/17.
ReactionAs if the ratings weren't enough, the telecast took it on the chin in the media today, with even its supporters providing nothing more than backhanded compliments.
Robert Bianco of the USA Today
absolutely kills the broadcast, taking Ryan Seacrest to task, "Actually, 'amateurish' doesn't begin to describe Ryan Seacrest, who, thanks to his obnoxious performance on E!'s pre-show, became the first host to wear out his welcome before he came in. Had he been content to simply keep the show moving, he might have been bearable. Instead, he worked the crowd like he was back at American Idol, making more of a nuisance of himself with each appearance, apparently not realizing that the occasion called for a classier act."
Alan Sepinwall of the New Jersey Star-Ledger
is equally upset, not so much at the presentation but by the winners. Tim Goodman
echoes his sentiment, "No Falco, no Gandolfini. Does anyone have a TV at the Emmy dumbassification of America factory? And can the TV industry stop this anger at HBO? Really, this isn't galling anymore, it's just sad and wrong."
The NY Times was more moderate in its analysis, but didn't exactly give Seacrest a glowing review. "Not that Mr. Seacrest... is unpleasant, but his presence didn’t exactly bring the evening up a notch." The Hollywood Reporter also took the middle ground, "Whatever shortcomings Seacrest or the telecast exhibited, the show did have some memorable moments, a modicum of humor and a lot of surprises."
There's no denying that FOX took a risk. Unfortunately for them, it appears that it backfired.
More from:
Televisionary,
Chicago Tribune,
Detroit Free Press,
Los Angeles Times,
Boston GlobeOdds & Ends• Stewie and Brian of Family Guy break into song with a parody of the current television landscape.
• Sally Field's uncensored Emmy acceptance speech. Can't tell if she's flustered, excited, exhausted or on drugs.
• Steve Carell, who reprises Ricky Gervais' role from the original version of The Office, realizes more than most that stealing from Gervais is a pretty good career move.
• Kanye West and Rainn Wilson duke it out. Kanye's take on the battle? "I never win."
• There's no video available yet, but Ray Romano's bleeped out sentence was "Frasier's ****ing my wife," a reference to his former Everybody Loves Raymond co-star Patricia Heaton. Heaton, who played Romano's wife on Raymond will appear alongside Kelsey Grammer in the new FOX series Back to You.
Keywords: Emmys, Emmy, Ratings, Nielsen, Ray Romano, Censored, Video, Kelsey Grammer, Patricia Heaton, Sally Field, Ray Romano, Kanye West, Rainn Wilson, Everybody Loves Raymond, Frasier, Family Guy